Rehoming App Wrapper and/or the Ohanaware App Kit

I honestly feel like I have tried to help Xojo grow (no denying my own income at the same time), but if they stay the course, not only myself, but others (with access to more data than me) are pretty certain it will be the end of the company and the product.

You definitely did help Xojo a lot. This is what I was trying to express. It’s not about platform specific code or Xojo’s focus/direction. It is that losing the most passionate and helpful community members and developers hurts Xojo tremendously.

Additionally as you mentioned in your post, when other people see what can be done in Xojo, it helps sell the product too. You really took Xojo to another level with your custom code and add-ons.

2 Likes

It was obvious even without any internal statements. :pensive:

Just the consecuences to stupid management

3 Likes

The CEO’s ‘Xojo is adequately staffed’ statement was a public pants-down moment.

1 Like

There was quite of bit of audible laughter when that was said at the end of an XDC.

1 Like

Didn’t they hire a technical documentation specialist last year?

https://tracker.xojo.com/xojoinc/xojo/-/issues/?sort=created_date&state=opened&label_name%5B%5D=Documentation&label_name%5B%5D=Bug&first_page_size=100

Genius doesn’t even fix bugs he puts on the bug list himself. No evangelist can fix Xojo’s systemic troubles.

https://tracker.xojo.com/xojoinc/xojo/-/issues/73840

There certainly was comments to that effect but I’m not seeing that actually prove itself in day to day practice

No, xojo TextEdit is already a RichEdit control that includes all the power of a word processor app, it is used in the WordPad app.

However, Xojo aproach to controls was really stupid with this, 99.9% you only need a plain text multiline control, being forced to use a full word processor control for that is nuts… The rest of the time when you actually need some styled text, the implementation is a Joke. :man_facepalming:t2:

1 Like

Are they even aware that the rest of the industry is transitioning to Declarative UI? Design the UI once and run it on everything from Desktop to mobile, to watch, to TV to VR headsets?

Pretty much how its going at this end, since trying to sell App Wrapper, several people have come forward and said the same thing, that the decline is expected to continue for the foreseeable future.

Thanks Paul.

It certainly reveals more than it should :slight_smile:

I guess there would be an equivalent control, all they need do is expose the editing controls and boom, they have an x-plat Rich Text Editor with RTF support… But…

1 Like

I dont see how it cant
They are being so … insular ? and avoiding most conversations / questions on their own forums
IF they are saying anything its in private so no one can see it
Probably NOT the best strategy at this point ESP if they are trying to reassure people that things are OK, they are in fine financial shape, etc (NONE of which I believe)

Like I said I have been told some things that lead me to believe they are NOT in good shape

1 Like

Let me say it so: as long as there are users buying the product they have no need to change anything on it. And look on Geoff. He will do this Business from now on how many years? 5? 10? And then it ends up. And I can’t see anybody paying a million for it. So I can’t see a future. While the CEO is at least in my age if not ten years older. So I guess: we will see what will be happened when he retires and how the followers will act if there are followers. All things we can say here are: speculative. So without any sense. I can also look into a crystal ball as a fortune teller, but it doesn’t help.

1 Like

Specifically the things I’ve heard suggest that sales are down a lot

To the point they are going to lay people off ? No idea

IF your business saw a sudden drop in revenue you might change what you’re doing
Will Geoff ? No idea

I have a hard time imagining anyone paying what Geoff might consider a reasonable offer for it as well
Esp if things ARE in a downturn
Such a buyer would have to put more money in to try & reverse that trend
I dont see it happening

Geoff ? Pretty sure he just recently celebrated a birthday and I think he’s 60 now

1 Like

With someone like him you can count on his bio posted somewhere

image

2 Likes

Oh I knew the date just didnt feel it was my place to share that :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like

Ah he is young and may work for 20 further years. At the end he will be the dinosaur of this industry and the oldest CEO…

…Centenarian Executive Officer

I know next to nothing in financial stuff, but if no one dare to buy with the given offer, can’t Geoff decrease the offer, up to the point where someone finally accepts? (like 20 cents :grin:).

1 Like

It is not that simple.

It would cost a lot to change course in a quick enough pace to see tangible returns, whoever takes it over isn’t going to see the benefits of change for potentially years, so they need deep pockets and most of the people who have those kinda pockets are gonna wanna see some significant return potential.

In the x-plat market space, Xojo is becoming less and less competitive. Not only does their x-plat vision go against everything else (which is less work, more platforms), each target is missing key features and Xojo’s hasn’t been adding support for newer controls.

Do you think you’ll ever see the “ComboButton” in Xojo, of course not, they *still don’t support ScrollViews from 2000. Let alone modern components like NavigationSplitView, Source Lists, system images, icons in buttons, buttons in the toolbar… etc etc… Pretty standard x-plat UI components.

SwiftUI : Button( "This is my button", systemImage: "folder" ) {}

5 Likes

Could he reduce what he’s asking ? Sure
Will he ? Entirely different question and I suspect he would not

1 Like

THIS.

2 Likes

Right. API2 with its splitting between desktop and different mobile platforms leaves Xojo dead in the water.

2 Likes